Note: The older content written as part of this blog was relevant at the time but may have since changed. Please don't hesitate to contact me for clarification.

Sunday, December 07, 2008

HAS THE ECONOMIST BEEN BANNED?

Bangkok Pundit and Thailand Jumped The Shark both have stories about a story in The Economist this week that, diplomatically speaking, looks at the role of the monarchy in Thailand's recent past. The story is here and an editorial can be found here.
I had an email from a regular reader of The Bangkok Bugle who is also a subscriber to The Economist. For the second week running, they have received an email apologising for logistics delays that have prevented the magazine from distributing in Thailand. The email says: "Priority has been extended, understandably, to relocating passengers over freight". So this week's edition of The Economist will not appear in Thailand, either for the reasons stated by the publisher or for other reasons.
With such a clear headline it's possible those involved in the distribution or selling of the magazine may have taken their own decision to decline to handle it this week (as opposed to any Government order), but
I think if the magazine has been banned the publisher will want the world to know. After all that's one of the points behind the articles. I also wonder if those Thailand-based advertisers that regularly appear in the magazine, such as Thai Airways and PTT, will get refunds for the past two weeks?
Some comments on the posts on the websites above talk about the article being translated and republished on Thai language websites. It's true that more people will read the translated story than the English original, but that doesn't stop the fact that republishing the translation is a breach of copyright, although I suspect
The Economist will not complain on this occasion. If you want the Thai language rights to content from The Economist you can expect to pay a significant amount. More than two years ago I looked at it but the costs were astronomical. There isn't a single Thai publisher that could make it work, in my view.
If you happen to see a copy of this edition inside Thailand please let me know.

UPDATE: Sunday, 2.20pm.
I have not been able to find any copies of The Economist edition in question, although I did see the new Asia editions of both Time and Newsweek which would cast doubt on the reason given by The Economist for its non appearance in Thailand this week.

UPDATE: Sunday, 7.20pm.
I've written a lot in the past about licensing, syndication and copyright issues. In this situation there are a number of translations of The Economist articles appearing on Thai language websites. The Economist has content syndication agreements for its content in more than 50 countries and in 25 languages around the world. It doesn't have one for Thai as far as I am aware, but that doesn't alter the fact that publication of a word-for-word translation is a breach of copyright.
For a bit more on syndication and licensing of The Economist click here.

6 comments:

Anonymous 4:12 PM  

Thanks, this is a very informative post, especially to someone who is outside Thailand. I hope you follow up on the questions you raised here about whether the Economist has been banned, and what it will do for its Thai advertisers. Also, I am curious to know if the Economist's Thailand correspondent is currently in the country, since he/she could be subject to arrest or much worse. If he/she is in the country and is identified, vigilante retribution is a real possibility, considering the recent tactics of the PAD and whoever is behind it.

(c) 2016 Written by Andrew Batt 4:36 PM  

The Economist, in common with other regional editions of global magazines, doesn't contain too much in the way of Thai advertising. Thai Airways, PTT and the Tourism Authority are about the only organisations that can both afford and benefit from it.

These articles were unattributed. I am not sure whether any reporters from the company would be legally responsible for what has been written, especially if it's been written by an editor in an office in Hong Kong.

Ladprao Roader 7:48 PM  

SCG also advertise in The Economist quite frequently. Let see if they will pull out soon...

Ladprao Roader 8:37 PM  

RE comment #1, I just want to point out to you that in 2002, when The Economist featured Thailand in its survey, it touched on this topic (i.e. the monarchy) a little and the Thaksin govt banned it. The Economist reacted by making the whole Thailand survey freely available on its website (usually, they allow only the subscribers to access)

Bangkok Bugle, regarding Thai advertiser, another one I have seen quite occasionally is none other than SCG. Let see if they will pull out in response to this...

Anonymous 11:42 PM  

Since that issue was not sold in Thailand, translating those articles into Thai isn't causing The Economist to directly forgo any income. Not that that alone excuses the copyright infringers.

That being said, those two articles have a historical significance, being the most directly critical articles to date regarding the Thai monarchy in the A-list international press. I doubt whether articles of this nature would ever appear in the FT, the Journal, or Foreign Affairs, even after the current era ends.

Unfortunately, this fact demands that the article be authoritatively translated into Thai and then spread as widely as possible and as soon as possible. I never heard of any samizdat publishers clamoring for syndication fees. In cases like this, the greater good triumphs over the rights of the writers.

- a regular reader

Anonymous 7:38 PM  

Insightful editorial, however I really dont know what The Economist would gain by publishing this cover story.

Are people worldwide really so curious about Thai Monarchy?

Wouldnt it cause much less trouble if they were to stay out of the topic?

Ask Me Anything ..

.. about the media and publishing industry in Thailand, and I will do my best to assist you. You can email your question to bkkandy AT myway.com.

Add me on Facebook

(c) The Bangkok Bugle 2006 - 2015. Email me at bkkandy AT myway.com for information.